Chapter 127: An old man and a small group accuse each other! Shen Qing cross-examines and refutes st

Under everyone's gaze.

Miao Luping stared at He Guang with loving eyes for a while.

Crystals appeared in his eyes.

Suddenly, Miao Luping raised her trembling right hand and pointed at Zhuo Ting aside.

She said with a trembling voice.

"She...she hit me!"

As soon as the words fell, the scene was in an uproar.

Miao Luping pointed to the ruler in Lin Hao's hand and said.

"The ring...the ring ruler, that's the ring ruler!"

"She beats me with that ruler every day! She hits me on the head every day!"

As she spoke, Miao Luping's eyes sparkled.

As if driven by a force that had been accumulated for a long time, it poured down the cheeks.

He Guang on the side wisely helped Miao Luping wipe the tears from her cheeks.

Then he also spoke.

"That's right! It's Aunt Zhuo Ting!"

"Aunt Zhuo Ting curses people every day! The one who gets scolded the most is Grandma Miao!"

"Sometimes if she doesn't listen to the scolding, she will get this "ruler"! Hit Grandma Miao on the head with a ruler! "

"And... there are other grandparents! There are many people who have been beaten by Aunt Zhuo Ting!"

"Also...there are other uncles and aunts in the orphanage who often beat and scold the grandparents!"

"The ruler...there are more than just those rulers! There are many uncles and aunts who have rulers in their hands!"

It was as if I had found a like-minded companion.

He Guang also seemed to gain strength from Miao Luping.

The whole emotion came out like a flash flood.

He said everything he wanted to say in one go.

At the end, He Guang couldn't help crying.

In the court.

The old man and the young man each shed tears and hugged each other.

This scene made everyone present moved.

Even the chief judge Gong Sunhui couldn't bear to destroy such a scene.

After much hesitation, Gongsun Hui decided to put the overall situation first.

He knocked his gavel and said.

"Please keep quiet!"

After everyone calms down.

Gongsun Hui said to Zhuo Ting.

"Zhuo Ting, do you have anything else to say?"

After being fooled several times in a row, Zhuo Ting no longer dared to speak.

He followed Shen Qing's hint.

He just kept silent.

Her silence at this time was tantamount to acquiescence in everyone's eyes.

Of course, even if she opened her mouth to explain, she couldn't explain it clearly.

Might as well leave everything to Lawyer Shen.

Shen Qing did not betray her trust and immediately raised his hand.

"Presiding judge, we need cross-examination!"

The presiding judge Gongsun Hui nodded slightly and said.

"Agree, please ask the defendant to submit cross-examination."

Shen Qing stood up and said.

“We have three doubts about the testimony provided by the plaintiff’s witnesses.”

"First, Witness No. 1 and Witness No. 2 who provided key testimony are both persons with limited capacity for civil conduct."

"The reliability of his testimony has yet to be verified and is not enough to be directly accepted!"

"Witness No. 1 Miao Luping suffers from intermittent mental illness. No one knows whether she is in the period of illness at this time."

"And we have no way of telling whether the testimony she gave is fact or her personal imagination."

"As for witness No. 2 He Guang, let alone that."

"A child who is only 13 years old is not yet mature in his ability to distinguish things and his judgment of attempts."

"For example, if he actually saw Ms. Zhuo Ting hitting Ms. Miao Luping on the head with a ruler."

"So is there a possibility that Ms. Zhuo Ting is giving Ms. Miao Luping a relaxing head massage?"

"Child He Guang, who lacked the ability to judge, mistakenly thought it was a beating, so he gave this testimony."

"Of course, I am just making an analogy. In fact, there may be countless possibilities."

"What I want to say is, is it too lax to determine the facts of the case based solely on the testimony of two people with limited capacity for civil conduct?"

"This is what I want to remind the court and hope the court can seriously consider this issue."

Although Shen Qing's words sounded like quibbling.

But I have to say that there is no fault in the theory.

Although this is not enough to convince people's hearts.

But it's enough to give people a glimpse of Shen Qing's personal abilities.

It attracted countless people to marvel.

In the dock.

Shen Qing continued.

“Second, I don’t know how the plaintiff found the so-called ‘rule’. "

"But I must remind everyone here that even if it is true as the two witnesses said, there is not only one such ruler, but there are even many, many."

"We can't just assume that a ruler made of newspapers and some fingerprints attached to it are used to hit people."

"I would like to ask everyone, can a ruler made of paper really hurt someone?"

"If you really wanted to hit someone, would you choose to use such a soft ruler?"

"I think this ruler may not be sufficient for the purpose of beating people."

"On the contrary, if you use it for massage, I think it should be just right!"

"So I don't agree with the idea that this kind of paper so-called "ruler" is associated with beating people! "

Hearing what Shen Qing said, some melon-eaters couldn't help but become suspicious.

Yes, can this kind of ruler really hurt someone?

Is this really for massage?

Shen Qing continued to express doubts.

"Third, witness No. 1 He Guang said that in addition to Zhuo Ting, other staff members of the welfare home often beat and scolded the residents."

"Regardless of whether what He Guang said is true or false, I just want to say... where is the evidence?"

"Even if we put aside the credibility of the two testimonies, we all know that witness testimony alone is not enough to determine the facts of the case."

"If the plaintiff claims that the witness testimony is valid, please provide corresponding supporting evidence!"

"Otherwise, we will not recognize it!"

Wow! Strong!

The gold medal lawyer of the Red Circle Law Firm is so terrifying!

Even if the grandfather-grandson relationship of the two witnesses is touching.

It cannot be determined that what they said must be the truth.

After all, this is a court.

It is not advisable to act emotionally!

It is still necessary to present facts and reason!

But when it comes to evidence.

Lin Hao is not panicked at all.

If it comes to other things, Lin Hao may not be able to produce them.